CUNY’s Self-Censoring Professors
Do we want communism? If we're hell-bent on an inclusive, democratic process, how do we reconcile that with our hostility towards the 1 Percent? I did enjoy Keith Gessen's "Laundry Day" essay perhaps because he seemed most willing to criticize the movement, or at least highlight its failures , but a lot of the others read like the authors typed up their notes and published them. They're merely observations, and they draw no clear conclusions.
Nevertheless, the majority of the material within this book has a self-congratulatory tone, as if something was accomplished, as if the government hasn't just made massive cuts to SNAP, as if TANF wasn't badly in need of funds, as if our president hasn't failed to raise taxes on the wealthy.
The American left would do well to either learn from Occupy's mistakes or forget it entirely, but this book, for the most part, encourages readers to do neither. Jan 10, Malcolm rated it liked it Shelves: marxism-and-the-left. Read other collections.
Also, read these things, get inspired and get out there to Occupy your local coffee chain store, open a day care centre in your local bank, demand that the super rich people and corporations pay their share of the tax or whatever gets your goat and focuses demands and pressure in your locality. This is a good collection of its time, but its topicality means there is much else to look at to even begin to get a feel for the movement.
View 1 comment.
Nov 02, Robert rated it liked it. Several photographs of what the occupy movement was like at its start. As someone who has been working with Occupy since the beginning, there was definitely a nostalgic sense that welled up inside me, longing for those days where so many were awake, aware, and willing help one another. However, given the fact the book only includes stuff that happened over the first couple months, the real sense of what has happened with so many occupations, the tribulations they've had to face, and so forth, is Several photographs of what the occupy movement was like at its start.
However, given the fact the book only includes stuff that happened over the first couple months, the real sense of what has happened with so many occupations, the tribulations they've had to face, and so forth, is lost. An in-depth study this is not. What's worse, there are names in here opining on occupations they know nothing about, and certainly never came to visit for long if at all.
Working with Occupy Atlanta, there is a rather patronizing account in the book of OA, and the history of struggle in Atlanta in about 3 pages, which is obviously not well detailed at all and certainly doesn't do it justice. It's written by Kung Li, a person who certainly didn't actually contribute work to OA on the ground I've never heard the name before, and I was working there every day. I wish the editors had made attempts to seriously investigate the movement, what people wanted, their hangups, cultural assumptions that must've been overcome And so much has happened since where the book ends, it really feels like the story has barely even begun to be told.
I'd check out probably another book on Occupy, perhaps written in late Or wait still until more of the story can be unfurled. Feb 13, Maria Arseniuk rated it really liked it. The essays vary in strength, but a worthwhile introduction to OWS from those who were there. Jan 22, Sean Carman rated it really liked it. It's hard not to love this book, because its publication represents such a noble endeavor. Slowly, over the past year or so, I've fallen in love with it.
But many of the entries, which consist of eyewitness accounts of the Zicotti Park encampment, seemed extremely well written but kind of slight. Like a witness describing events without being able to draw them into a larger context. Maybe that was the point.
That said, however, this book is worth purchasing solely for the reprint of the speech Slavoj Zizek gave at the park, "Writing in Red Ink," in which he argues that the reason the Occupy Movement didn't have a slogan or talking points is simply that we haven't yet developed a language for the revolution we all so urgently need and want. That's the best and clearest answer I've heard as to why the Occupy movement lacked a message, and the best and clearest explanation of why, ultimately, it needs to develop one.
May 19, Tiredstars rated it liked it. Know what to expect, and I don't think you'll be disappointed. It was published not too long after the start of OWS, so doesn't cover the later development of the movement at all. Much of what's in the book could be familiar ground for people who have followed the movement closely, but I haven't. Where the book is strongest Know what to expect, and I don't think you'll be disappointed. Where the book is strongest is probably in documenting the changing feelings and experiences of those on the ground.
And it certainly doesn't shy away from worry about the future - the book starts with the authors surprised by their optimism, and ends with problems with laundry and the daily issues of simply maintaining the camp as winter closes in. Nov 03, Chris rated it liked it Shelves: american , politics , journalism.
Is There Still Alternative Culture in New York?
Hardly an 18th Brumaire , but Occupy was no July Revolution, probably for the better. And for the occasional salient details that give life to what occupying in this way Hardly an 18th Brumaire , but Occupy was no July Revolution, probably for the better. Shouldn't be a last or even first word on the movement--"scenes," as the title promises, is an apt word for what it gives, but its "America" is a rather limited one. Oct 14, Gareth rated it it was amazing. Petty decisions such as how to manage laundry a multi-day debate , what kind of storage bins to buy they had to be fair trade and procured through Craigslist , and how to put limits on the drumming circles without alienating them some considered this a civil rights issue often sucked up hours of valuable time when put to consensus-based discussion in General Assemblies.
In the process, they ignored generations of accumulated wisdom about how to mobilize successful social movements, even to the point of refusing to isolate and organize around specific demands. Jason Hickel is a postdoctoral fellow at the London School of Economics. His research focuses on Southern Africa and covers issues related to development, democracy, labor, and political conflict. Read more reviews by Jason. Click here to cancel reply. Explore the latest social science book reviews by academics and experts. Facebook Facebook. Book Review: Occupy!
Previous post Next post. Leave A Comment. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.
- Join Kobo & start eReading today.
- Prosthetic Treatment of the Edentulous Patient (5th Edition).
- Bioinformatics for Geneticists.
- Mark Greif | Department of English.
- Festival of Fear.
- Navigation menu.
- Opportunities in Government Careers.
In the immediate afterglow of the emergence of Occupy Wall Street OWS in fall and the proliferation of Occupy encampments in cities throughout North America and around the world, there was a parallel explosion of written work that sprang up in very short order to occupy virtual and real bookshelves and seeking to comment definitively upon the movement, its significance, and its future. To some extent, critical intellectual production of, with, and about social movements has often followed this pattern. In the wake of the Zapatista uprising in , volumes of ink were — and continue to be — spilled including by this author exploring the movement and its resonance.
Most users should sign in with their email address. If you originally registered with a username please use that to sign in. To purchase short term access, please sign in to your Oxford Academic account above.
How theory met practice . . . and drove it absolutely crazy
Don't already have an Oxford Academic account? Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers the University's objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide. Sign In or Create an Account. Sign In. Advanced Search.
Article Navigation. Close mobile search navigation Article Navigation. Volume Blumenkranz, K.